Proud Partner for Over 40 Years

Founded in 1980 by Gary Garlesky, CLU, and licensed to do business in both the State’s of Ohio and Georgia, the Garlesky Insurance Agency, LLC was built by Gary from the ground up through hard work and dedication and many referrals along the way. Aaron Rogers joined our team as an associate agent back in 2008 and has since taken on the role of Principal Agent as of February 2022. He continues to provide our customers superior service and product knowledge in multiple lines of insurance.   We welcomed Amanda Gard to the team in September of 2022 and she has become a vital part the Garlesky Insurance Agency.  As an Associate Agent, she is ready to assist with new Auto, Home, Renters, and Business insurance along with continuing to manage policy changes, billing inquires, certificate requests, policy reviews and more.

We value our clients and their referrals and look forward to continuing the relationships that have been ongoing for over 40 years as well as creating new ones. We sell and service all the insurance products that most people and businesses need including; Home, Auto, Life, Business Insurance, IRA’s, Annuities, Mutual funds and 401(k)’s. Click request a quote for any and all of your insurance needs.

Our happy clients

I've been with Garlesky insurance for years. I've got everything through them. They're always thorough, professional, and responsive

-Ryan J.

Amanda has been the absolute best. Super knowledgeable and VERY helpful! All around great people work here!

-Brian D.

Great people and business, easy to work with and thorough. They put together a business liability quote for my company.

-Nick T.

I was looking to save some money on my homeowner's insurance policy. This company cut my cost to less than half of what my old policy was charging! Great people and great service! Thanks Amanda and associates for helping me save money!


I was using a previous agency for my Homeowner’s Insurance and I wasn’t happy with their professionalism. I contacted this office and spoke to Amanda. Not only did she get me better rates on my Homeowners insurance and car insurance, but she educated me on things I wouldn’t have otherwise...

-Cindy C.

Attention oriented with what you need and want, goes above and beyond what you are looking for in the Insurance industry!!! All of the dedication makes a difference in this crazy world, but they go through exactly what is correct in your needs! Keep up the amazing work!!!

-Kathryn S.

Amanda and Aaron have been wonderful. They found me an affordable policy even in today's economy. They have on top of customer service and anything I need, gets done promptly and accurately. Having an agent take care of my insurance needs has made such a difference and I don't have...


Great Agency !!!!

-Jon G.

This is an excellent Insurance Agency! They worked very hard shopping for the best rate with the coverage I needed when I was unhappy with my old companies rates. I would recommend them to anyone!

-Steve P.

Five Stars!

-Aaron C.

I wanted to give feedback on the excellent customer service from Aaron Rogers with Garlesky Insurance Agency. I have gone through some changes with my family and he has helped me through each step. He is always looking for better plans for me and my family. I really appreciate the...

-Cindy B.

Very informative and responsive! They worked with me while I was buying my first home and got me a deal to bundle my home and auto!

-Heidi K.

They have always treated me with respect and always been up front with me. And very nice to talk to.

-Mike S.

The people that I talk to want good coverage. I think the Garlesky Insurance team is focused on taking care of clients and it shows in their everyday communication!

-Darrell Y

Very helpful staff. Joelle is wonderful and follows through. Very helpful staff. They are wonderful and they follow through.

-Cynthia R.

Very quick to respond and helpful

-Jeffrey D.

The Garlesky Insurance Agency has taken good care of me whether it was with my car or with my house on any insurance claim I've ever had.

-Robert R.

Always been nice and understanding, even if I'm not knowledgable on the subject.

-Derek H.

When I call with questions or problems, I get them answered and resolved quickly and patiently.

-Mary B.

Responsive to our needs. Always works with us to keep costs down.


We've been with Gary over 30 years and he has always worked with us to keep our premiums reasonable and low.


Garlesky agency services all our business needs and personal needs, Alots of accounts. They are very personable, prompt in all matters.

-Hea K

We have been clients of Mr Garlesky for many years and we have never been disappointed with the service he or Nationwide has provided.

-Jack C.

Great Service!

-Glenn R.

Been there long time. Always nice, helpful, understanding.

-Shelley T.

Been with agency for many many years

-Michael M.

I have been with Gary Garlesky for many years and they have always taken care of all my issues with the car. Every time I’ve gone into office they are so friendly and helpful.

-Linda H.

Gary and his team offer great insurance policies and insight. It's awesome to know that my family and I are taken care of in the event of a disaster.

-Darrell Y.

When I need to have questions answered about my insurance coverage, they are always willing to help out! Thanks for the good service.

-Bruce S.

Always responsive to inquiries

-Karen M.

Aaron Rogers has been very helpful whenever we needed his assistance.

-Naresh S.

They are wonderful!

-Eric P.

Very nice and knowledgeable staff!

-Gisele P.

Gary is a personal and great friend for years, he and his company have always protected our family especially during difficult times. No one better!

-Darryl B.

Gary and Jessica always look out for our best interests. Any time I call they both are very pleasant and accommodating. Simply the Best.

-Cheryl B.

We have been with Gary for close to 35 years, he has taken good care of us during this time and I can not see us working with anyone else.

-Kevin B.

We have been with the agency for many years and have always felt secure in the way they handle our insurance. On a VERY RARE occasion that we needed them, we have been taken care of with satisfaction

-Donald M.

Leave us a review

The greatest testament that our customers can provide is by sharing their experience.

View more
American Modern
Hagerty Insurance
Liberty Mutual Insurance
National General
Ohio FAIR Plan
State Auto Insurance
The Hartford
Trexis Insurance
US Assure
Why You Need Motorcycle, Boat, and RV Insurance
April 19, 2024

Why You Need Motorcycle, Boat, and RV Insurance

Protecting Your Outdoor Adventures Your outdoor hobbies are your chance to soak up the sun, enjoy the fresh air, and […]

latest blogs

Please read our new articles to save more!

Read More

Securities offered through Lincoln Douglas Investments, LLC., Member FINRA/SIPC.

Association Association
©2024. All rights reserved. | Powered by Zywave Websites

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.